“Attention is not impact” and other challenges for altmetrics

Altmetrics should be harnessed not to replace any existing metrics, but rather to expand the tools available to demonstrate the diffusion of science.” Cassidy Sugimoto, Assistant Professor, School of Informatics and Computing, Indiana University

In 2010, Jason Priem and his colleagues published the altmetrics manifesto in which they stated that “the growth of new, online scholarly tools allows us to make new filters; these altmetrics reflect the broad, rapid impact of scholarship in this burgeoning ecosystem. We call for more tools and research based on altmetrics.” The manifesto highlights the pitfalls of the existing systems of: peer review; citation counting; and the Journal Impact Factor. In response to the issues that are highlighted, altmetrics calls for an expansion of what is considered to be impact and points to how altmetrics can enhance current systems of measuring scholarly impact.

Professor Sugimoto in her guest post on the Wiley exchanges blog in turn considers the pitfalls of altmetrics and suggests that the current altmetrics, high in its ambition, does not fully take into account the full diversity of academic activity. Sugimoto ends the post in the same sentiment as the altmetrics manifesto in that these new metrics should complement and not serve to replace the traditional measures of scholarly impact.

Diana Hayes
A key part of the team, Diana is achievement-oriented, forward-thinking and strategic in creating a high-yielding network of interested academics, universities and related associations. Her research and content have created genuine engagement amongst both candidates and employers resulting in a network of 250,000 academics. Diana’s experience is in sales, marketing, event management and business development.

How to tailor a job application

In preparation for the upcoming academic year, universities are beginning to accept applications for their top faculty positions. Peter Matthews, Senior Lecturer in Social Policy at the Faculty of Social Sciences at the University of Stirling,…

How Applied’s recruitment tool can help HE tackle gender bias in recruitment

CEO of Global Academy Jobs.com Wendy Stone talks to Kate Glazebrook, the CEO and co-founder of Applied, about the ground-breaking work Applied are doing to tackle unconscious recruitment bias, and what the implications are for…

Leave a Reply